Old Toy Repair

I have an old toy rolling pin from my childhood.  It is missing a handle.  Lucky for me, I still had the rolling pin that attaches.  I used the metal template to find out how wide the widest part of the handle is, and traced it onto the top of this dowel after I drilled the hole for the pin.  Theoretically, I can use my belt sander to shape the dowel and match the other handle.